Legislation on medical assistance in dying (MAiD) for people living with mental illness: ..." MISSING THE MARK"

Legislation on medical assistance in dying (MAiD) for people living with mental illness: ..." MISSING THE MARK"

User profile image Bill - EENet Yoda Master

in News, policy and advocacy |

Ramona Coelho,  John Maher,  Trudo Lemmens explain the impact and implications:

Missing the mark on a profound social change with MAiD for mental illness

The Trudeau government rushed MAiD legislation for political reasons. The law’s defenders invoke the right to equality while ignoring serious dangers.

... Ottawa’s answer to the Quebec court was Bill C-7, which took effect March 2021. It no longer restricted MAID to situations where death is “reasonably foreseeable,” and introduced a new de facto access track for disabled Canadians whose death is not “reasonably foreseeable.” Additionally, the Trudeau government suddenly reversed its previous commitment to exclude MAiD for mental illness alone, with NDP and Conservatives in clear opposition. It accepted a Senate-introduced “sunset clause,” which delayed MAiD for the sole reason of mental illness until March 2023. We believe the decision to rush through the legislation was political and failed to consider the unique dangers of expanding MAiD outside the end-of-life context and particularly for reasons of mental illness. ...

... From the world-renowned CAMH (Centre for Addiction and Mental Health) to the Canadian Association for Suicide Prevention, experts have warned that it is impossible to predict, as per the language of the law, the “irremediability” of mental illness for any individual. Critics say this raises the spectre of people who are not near death, but who have mental illness, being provided physician-assisted death based on unscientific assessments by physicians claiming supposed “irremediability” — at times where they may be suffering despair that is actually resolvable. ..

Please read the article herehttps://policyoptions.irpp.org...-for-mental-illness/



 


User profile image Robert Olcott - EENet Yoda Master

Will 'Alzheimer's' be considered 'Mental Illness' ? ? ?

0

User profile image Jenny - EENet Super Ninja

Wonder how extensive the people in mental disability communities were consulted.

0

User profile image Angie Hamilton - EENet Super Ninja

Thanks for sharing Bill. It's going to be very distressing for family caregivers.

0

User profile image Ivan Evers - EENet Ninja

DSM-V lists Alzheimer's disease as a subtype of dementia (neurocognitive disorders) so it's a slippery slope

0